Over 186,000 T+L readers completed the 2024 survey.
The final scores are averages of these responses.
Of the San Juan Islands (No.
Daniela Duncan/Getty Images
2), by contrast, was as much a draw for its in-town buzz as its wild spaces.
We love the fact that there are no cars just horses and bikes, says a reader.
Regardless of what kind of island lifestyle appeals, youll find it somewhere in the list ahead.
Marc Romanelli/Getty Images
And it seems every reader has their go-to isle.
It’s a total package.
The whole area is perfect.
Another voter rhapsodized about Little St. Simons, calling it truly a magical place.
It’s wonderful to be able to unplug and connect with nature.
St. Simons is my favorite for nightlife, said one, with another writing simply Absolutelygorgeous islands!
Some of the most beautiful Ive been to.
The Full List
1.
Amelia Island, Florida
Reader Score: 86.93
3.
Mackinac Island, Michigan
Reader Score: 86.73
4.
Marthas Vineyard, Massachusetts
Reader Score: 84.17
5.
Florida Keys, Florida
Reader Score: 83.48
6.
Cumberland Island, Georgia
Reader Score: 83.20
7.
San Juan Islands, Washington
Reader Score: 83.10
8.
Nantucket, Massachusetts
Reader Score: 83.06
9.
Kiawah Island, South Carolina
Reader Score: 82.61
10.
Sanibel Island, Florida
Reader Score: 82.32
11.
Hilton Head Island, South Carolina
Reader Score: 81.97
12.
Mount Desert Island, Maine
Reader Score: 81.33
13.
Fire Island, New York
Reader Score: 81.03
14.
Captiva Island, Florida
Reader Score: 80.78
15.
South Padre Island, Texas
Reader Score: 80.54
