Nowadays, the building is a five-star boutique hotel calledVilla Paola.

Tropea seems to have a way of enchanting people.

Known as the Pearl of the Tyrrhenian, this village casts a siren call.

Sanctuary of Santa Maria dell Isola in Tropea, Italy

Credit:Laura Itzkowitz/Travel + Leisure

During our time there, I felt its irresistible pull and Im not the only one.

With that, the evening was transformed from pleasant to unforgettable.

Long tendrils of caper vines hang on the stone walls and bursts of fuchsia bougainvillea shock the senses.

Aerial view of the free beach in Tropea, Italy

Laura Itzkowitz/Travel + Leisure

But unlike Taormina, Tropea is still relatively under-the-radar.

Like Taormina, Tropea is a hilltop village perched above the sea.

Yet the village is shrouded in myths and legends.

The pool and terraced gardens at Villa Paola in Tropea, Italy

Laura Itzkowitz/Travel + Leisure

One of the most important towns on the Coast of the Gods, Tropea was supposedly founded by Hercules.

The region was part of Magna Graecia, with Greeks living here before the Romans.

Nowadays, its best known for its pristine beaches and its prized red onions.

A street scene in Tropea, Italy

Laura Itzkowitz/Travel + Leisure

As soon as I waded in, I spotted little fish swimming around me an extremely unusual sight.

A mermaid swimming in the gentle waves.

Or rather, a tween wearing a mermaid tail.

La Capannina farm stand in Tropea, Italy

Laura Itzkowitz/Travel + Leisure

Apparently, her daughter has been obsessed with them since she was a little girl.

Mermaids, monks, and gods these are some of the characters you might encounter in and around Tropea.

When it came time to check out of Villa Paola the next day, we didnt want to leave.

The tranquil setting combined with an invisible energetic force had cast its spell.

If stored in a cool, dry place, theyll last until Christmas, the woman there told us.

After that, well just have to return for more magic and onions.