In this corner of the world, theres no wrong choice.

Over 186,000 T+L readers completed the 2024 survey.

The final scores are averages of these responses.

View of Soufriere village (Dominica)

gydyt0jas/Getty Images

In Anguilla (No.

3), fantastic beaches and warm, welcoming locals were a throughline of reader feedback.

Its remote, but truly a paradise to relax and read a book.

A beautiful secluded white sand beach on Atlantic side of Dominica, Eastern Caribbean.

Derek Galon/Getty Images

One word: amazing.

In the U.S. Virgin Islands, meanwhile,St.

  1. stood out for its natural beauty and commitment to land conservation.

We love to snorkel, and the peace and quiet of this island.

We love the friendly people and the fact that so much of the island is a park.

Three familiar spots re-entered the fray this year after dropping off the list Cuba (No.

2), Bermuda (No.

19), and St. Croix (No.

One reader calls it an incredible nature reserve like no other place left on the planet.

But one true aficionado put it most elegantly: What a wonderful secret island to discover.

Get here any way it’s possible for you to.

T+L Reader

What a wonderful secret island to discover.

Get here any way you’ve got the option to.

The Full List

1.

Dominica

Reader Score: 92.47

2.

Cuba

Reader Score: 90.61

3.

Anguilla

Reader Score: 90.02

4.

St. Lucia

Reader Score: 88.70

5.

St. John, U.S. Virgin Islands

Reader Score: 87.68

6.

Aruba

Reader Score: 87.13

7.

Turks and Caicos

Reader Score: 86.92

8.

Harbour Island, Bahamas

Reader Score: 86.73

9.

Vieques, Puerto Rico

Reader Score: 86.57

10.

St. Barts

Reader Score: 86.44

11.

Exumas, Bahamas

Reader Score: 86.30

12.

St. Vincent and the Grenadines

Reader Score: 85.80

13.

Eleuthera, Bahamas

Reader Score: 84.77

14.

Nevis

Reader Score: 84.48

15.

Grenada

Reader Score: 84.46

16.

Bonaire

Reader Score: 84.36

17.

Cayman Islands

Reader Score: 84.19

18.

Virgin Gorda, British Virgin Islands

Reader Score: 84.16

19.

Bermuda

Reader Score: 84.05

20.

Culebra, Puerto Rico

Reader Score: 83.35

21.

Jost Van Dyke, British Virgin Islands

Reader Score: 83.07

22.

Jamaica

Reader Score: 82.74

23.

Martin

Reader Score: 81.81

24.

St. Kitts

Reader Score: 81.51

25.

St. Croix, U.S. Virgin Islands

Reader Score: 81.44