Is it possible to have a less-than-incredible vacation in Hawaii?

Over 186,000 T+L readers completed the 2024 survey.

The final scores are averages of these responses.

Teams of rowers go past a traditional hut on the island of Hawaii

Laura La Monaca/Travel + Leisure

Of Lanai (No.

5), one reader called it a remote island that gives off an authentic Hawaiian feel.

Its like visiting a different world, with a one-hour boat ride back to real life, another said.

View of palm trees along the coast of Hawaii

Laura La Monaca/Travel + Leisure

  1. more rugged, easygoing feel drew plenty of admirers.

We decided to shift from vacation to volunteering, which made for a rewarding trip.

Said another, the true meaning of aloha is here.

Visit active volcanoes and green-sand beaches.

The lava fields and open spaces feel like a step back in time.

Whatever you are looking to do, you’ll find it on the Big Island.

One reader says what all the rest are thinking: This island has quickly become my favorite.

T+L Reader

The Big Island is truly unique among the Hawaiian islands.

The lava fields and open spaces feel like a step back in time.

Whatever you are looking to do, you’ll find it on the Big Island.

The Full List

1.

Island of Hawaii

Reader Score: 88.04

2.

Maui

Reader Score: 87.81

3.

Kauai

Reader Score: 87.28

4.

Oahu

Reader Score: 86.36

5.

Lanai

Reader Score: 85.68